Your practice tempo is half the speed where the passage falls apart. Find the failure point first, halve it, then climb back up in steps small enough that each one feels owned before you take the next. The metronome sets the pulse; the recording tells you whether you actually held it.
Your quoted top speed is a story
The number you tell other musicians — "I can play it at 120" — is a story, and the story is almost always slightly ahead of the truth. It is the tempo where you got it right once, or where the first chorus starts clean before the second chorus drifts, or where the hard measure is still a coin flip. Your ears lie while you play, especially about tempo. I have said "this is clean at 96" and then listened back to a take where the second chorus was already rushing. The take felt locked. It was not.
Find the failure tempo
The failure tempo is the fastest speed at which the passage breaks audibly. It is not the speed where it feels hard; it is the speed where a note chokes, a rhythm slips, or a finger lands in the wrong place. Set your metronome low, play the passage two or three times clean, then raise the tempo by five or ten BPM and repeat. Keep raising until it breaks. The number just before the break is your ceiling.
C major scale fragment in eighth notes at 60 BPM: C D E F G A B C.
Start at half, earn every step
Half of the failure tempo is where the real practice happens. If the passage breaks at 120 BPM, your starting line is 60 BPM, not 80 and not "comfortably slow." 60 BPM means one beat per second. That is slow enough to catch a finger preparing too late, a pick stroke aiming wrong, or a tension you cannot feel at speed.
I used to start at about 80% of my target and wonder why the hard measure stayed hard. The hard measure stayed hard because I was still practicing near the edge of control. Half speed is boring and honest. It is where I noticed that my ring finger was late on the third note of every four-note group in the G7 arpeggio. At speed that flaw hid inside the blur; at half speed it was the only thing I could see.
Ladder up in small increments
Once the passage is clean at half speed, raise the metronome by about 5%. From 60 BPM a 5% step is 63 BPM. From 100 BPM it is 105 BPM. These small jumps force you to own the tempo; a 20% jump lets you bluff through on momentum and hides the same weak spots. Play the passage two or three times clean at the new tempo before you raise again. If it breaks, drop back one rung and stay there until it is easy.
This is why slow practice fits a daily practice loop better than a heroic weekend session. The ladder only works if you climb it often.
What slow practice does not fix
Slow practice is a scalpel, not a blanket. It fixes motion, timing, and finger placement. It does not fix a phrase you cannot hear in your head. If you do not know where the line wants to go, playing it slowly just makes the uncertainty last longer. It also will not build endurance or fix a bad fingering you have repeated a thousand times at speed; bad motion practiced slowly is still bad motion.
The other thing it does not fix is repertoire decay. A passage you owned last month can still fall apart this month if you stopped playing it. I wrote about that in repertoire decays during gig prep. Slow practice rebuilds cleanly, but only if you keep returning.
How you know the tempo held
The recording is the only verdict that counts. Your hands lie about tempo while you play. I have finished takes convinced the tempo was rock solid, then heard the recording drift ahead by the final chorus. So I rate the take twice: once from inside the performance, once after listening back.
Edgars does not grade your tone, pitch, or timing, and it does not analyse the audio. It records the take and lets you rate it. That is enough. The honest number, tied to a recording that sounds the same every time, does the work your gut cannot. Over weeks the ratings pile up in the journal that writes itself, and the trend tells you whether your ceiling is actually moving.